Optimizing website performance with GTmetrix and PageSpeed Insights

28 October 2023 - WebOps Platforms Bug Tracking & Feedback Software Web Development & Design

Share this article :

Share Insight

Share the comparison insight with others

Optimizing Website Performance with GTmetrix and PageSpeed Insights

Website performance is a critical factor that can make or break the user experience on your site. A faster website not only keeps visitors engaged but also has a positive impact on search engine rankings. To assess and improve website performance, many web developers and site owners turn to tools like GTmetrix and PageSpeed Insights. These tools provide valuable insights and recommendations for optimizing your site. However, you might have noticed that your GTmetrix Performance Score is different from what you see in PageSpeed Insights, and this can lead to confusion. In this article, we’ll delve into why these differences exist and how to optimize your website’s performance using both of these tools.

Why the Discrepancy in Performance Scores?

It’s not uncommon for your website’s performance scores to vary from one tool to another, such as GTmetrix, PageSpeed Insights, WebPageTest, and web.dev. These differences arise due to various factors, including the implementation of Google Lighthouse, testing methodologies, testing locations, and other configurations.

While we’ll primarily focus on GTmetrix and PageSpeed Insights, the underlying principles apply to any tool that utilizes Lighthouse for performance assessments. Let’s explore the key differences among these tools:

GTmetrix

Loads pages with a real browser (Chrome).
Default view: Desktop (1366 x 768).
Uses Lighthouse with custom audits.
Allows the application of analysis options if selected.
Unthrottled Connection (default).
Testing location: Vancouver, Canada (default).
Consistent hardware used across all locations.
Does not use Lantern (Observed mode).

WebPageTest

Loads pages with a real browser (Chrome).
Default view: Desktop (1900 x 1200).
Uses Lighthouse.
Allows the application of analysis options if selected.
Throttled connection: Cable (default).
Testing location: Dulles, USA (default).
Does not use Lantern (Observed mode).

web.dev

Uses headless/emulated browsers.
Default view: Mobile (1080 x 1920, Emulated Moto G4).
Uses default Lighthouse.
Throttled CPU for mobile tests.
Throttled Connection (likely Slow 4G connection).
Tests are likely launched from US servers.
Utilizes mid to high-tier mobile CPU/memory power (e.g., Moto G4).
Uses Lantern (Simulated mode).

Google PageSpeed Insights

Uses headless/emulated browsers.
Default views: Mobile (412 x 823) and Desktop (1350 x 940).
Uses default Lighthouse.
Throttled CPU for mobile tests.
Throttled connection (likely Slow 4G for mobile).
Tests are likely geolocated in one of 4 global locations.
Likely similar CPU/memory resources as web.dev (mobile tests only).
Uses Lantern (Simulated mode).

In summary, these tools differ in terms of hardware, connection speed, locations, screen resolutions, and testing methodologies. GTmetrix and WebPageTest use real browsers to load pages and offer more flexibility in changing various test options. However, tools like PageSpeed Insights and web.dev utilize headless/emulated browsers and network throttling to simulate page loads under different conditions.

A significant factor contributing to score variations is the use of Lantern by the Google tools, which results in different page loading behaviors and, consequently, varying Performance scores and test results.

Optimizing Website Performance

Now that we understand why different tools yield varying results, let’s focus on how to optimize your website’s performance using GTmetrix and PageSpeed Insights. Since GTmetrix provides a more realistic user experience by using a real browser, it’s often considered more practical for performance optimization. Here are some optimization tips:

GTmetrix Optimization Tips:

Minimize Image Sizes: Compress images to reduce loading times without compromising quality.
Leverage Browser Caching: Set appropriate cache headers to allow browsers to store resources locally, reducing subsequent load times.
Minify CSS and JavaScript: Reduce the file sizes of these resources by removing unnecessary characters and whitespace.
Enable GZIP Compression: Compress your website’s files to reduce the amount of data transmitted to the user’s browser.
Eliminate Render-Blocking Resources: Prioritize the loading of critical resources, so your page appears faster.
Optimize Server Response Time: Ensure your web hosting environment is efficient and responsive.

PageSpeed Insights Optimization Tips:

Focus on Core Web Vitals: Pay attention to metrics like Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), First Input Delay (FID), and Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) as they directly impact user experience and search rankings.
Minimize Cumulative Layout Shift: Prevent unexpected layout shifts by defining dimensions for media, using set size attribute dimensions for ads, and preloading content with appropriate placeholders.
Optimize for Mobile: Ensure that your website performs well on mobile devices, as mobile-friendliness is crucial for user experience and SEO.
Serve Images in Next-Gen Formats: Use modern image formats like WebP to enhance image loading performance.
Avoid Excessive DOM Size: Keep your Document Object Model (DOM) size in check by reducing the complexity of your web pages.
Improve JavaScript Efficiency: Efficient JavaScript execution is essential for faster loading and rendering of pages.

By following these optimization tips, you can improve your website’s performance on both GTmetrix and PageSpeed Insights. Remember that every website is unique, so it’s essential to analyze your site’s specific issues and address them accordingly.

In conclusion, optimizing website performance is a multifaceted task, and it’s natural to see variations in scores across different performance analysis tools. Understanding these differences and applying the right optimizations can help you enhance your website’s speed and overall user experience. So, whether you rely on GTmetrix, PageSpeed Insights, or other tools, the goal remains the same: to deliver a fast and efficient website to your visitors. For further insights, you can also check out this comparison and this article.